Heroes and Villains by The Beach Boys

Released in July 1967 as a single and later included on the Beach Boys’ album Smiley Smile, Heroes and Villains is one of the band’s most ambitious and enigmatic songs, representing a pivotal moment in their artistic evolution. Written by Brian Wilson and Van Dyke Parks, the track was produced by Brian Wilson and recorded across multiple sessions from May 1966 to June 1967 at studios like Gold Star, Western, and Columbia in Los Angeles. Featuring the Beach Boys—Brian, Carl, and Dennis Wilson, Mike Love, Al Jardine, and Bruce Johnston—alongside the Wrecking Crew, the single peaked at #12 on the Billboard Hot 100, a modest success compared to earlier hits like Good Vibrations.

Heroes and Villains was conceived as the centerpiece of Smile, Brian Wilson’s unfinished follow-up to Pet Sounds (1966), envisioned as a “teenage symphony to God.” Intended to rival The Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, Smile was a sprawling concept album blending Americana, psychedelia, and avant-garde elements. Heroes and Villains was meant to anchor its narrative, but the project’s collapse due to Brian’s mental health struggles, band tensions, and label pressure led to its release as a standalone single and a simplified version on Smiley Smile. The song’s complex production and fragmented structure reflect both Brian’s genius and the chaotic circumstances surrounding its creation.

The recording process was extraordinarily intricate, involving over 50 sessions and costing tens of thousands of dollars. Brian employed a modular approach, similar to Good Vibrations, recording segments like “cantina” and “barnyard” sections that he planned to weave together. The Wrecking Crew, including Hal Blaine on drums and Carol Kaye on bass, provided eclectic instrumentation—banjo, organ, tack piano, and percussion—while the Beach Boys’ harmonies, led by Brian and Carl, added emotional depth. The final single, trimmed to three minutes, was a compromise, omitting much of the original’s sprawling vision, which disappointed Brian but captivated fans and critics.

Heroes and Villains had a profound, if complex, legacy. It influenced progressive rock and indie music, with its episodic structure inspiring artists like The Who and Radiohead. The Smile sessions, including unreleased fragments, became legendary, culminating in Brian’s 2004 solo completion of Smile. The song’s abstract narrative and psychedelic vibe resonated with the 1967 Summer of Love, though its commercial underperformance marked a decline in the Beach Boys’ chart dominance. Modern listeners occasionally note its dense lyrics and male-centric perspective, but Heroes and Villains endures as a testament to Brian’s visionary ambition.

Inspiration and Creation

The inspiration for Heroes and Villains stemmed from Brian Wilson’s desire to create a cinematic, uniquely American epic. In 1966, fresh off Pet Sounds’ critical acclaim, Brian sought to surpass The Beatles’ experimentalism. He collaborated with Van Dyke Parks, a poet and lyricist whose erudite, whimsical style complemented Brian’s musical vision. Parks drew inspiration from Western films, comic books, and American history, crafting a surreal narrative about heroes and villains in a mythic Old West. Brian, meanwhile, was influenced by classical music, vaudeville, and Phil Spector’s production techniques, aiming to blend pop with avant-garde storytelling.

Brian’s creative process was both innovative and obsessive. He envisioned Heroes and Villains as a multi-part suite, with sections evoking different moods—saloon brawls, pastoral landscapes, and urban chaos. He composed on piano, sketching themes like the “Bicycle Rider” motif, later repurposed in Smile’s Surf’s Up. Parks’ lyrics, filled with wordplay and imagery like “stand or fall in the neighborhood” and “Cantina Dan,” created an abstract, almost impressionistic tale. Brian recorded fragments separately, intending to edit them into a cohesive whole, a process that pushed the limits of 1960s studio technology and his own mental stamina.

Recording sessions from May 1966 to June 1967 were grueling. Brian worked with engineers like Larry Levine, using multi-track recorders to capture dozens of takes. The Wrecking Crew provided a kaleidoscope of sounds, from banjo plucks to thunderous percussion, while the Beach Boys’ harmonies, layered meticulously, evoked a choral grandeur. Band tensions, particularly Mike Love’s skepticism about Parks’ esoteric lyrics, and Capitol Records’ impatience for a hit added pressure. Brian’s drug use and mental health struggles further complicated the process, leading to Smile’s abandonment. The single, assembled in 1967, was a condensed version, retaining the song’s essence but omitting its full scope.

External factors shaped the song’s creation. The 1966–1967 music scene, with The Beatles’ Revolver and the psychedelic boom, demanded innovation, and Brian aimed to lead the charge. The counterculture’s embrace of surreal art and Americana made Heroes and Villains timely, though its complexity puzzled some fans accustomed to California Girls. Its release in July 1967, during the Summer of Love, aligned with the era’s experimental spirit, but its chart performance reflected the Beach Boys’ struggle to maintain relevance amid newer acts like Jimi Hendrix.

Themes and Conveyed Content

Lyrically, Heroes and Villains is an abstract, almost cinematic exploration of good versus evil, set in a mythic American landscape. The narrator observes a struggle between heroes and villains, with cryptic references to a “Spanish and Indian home,” a cantina brawl, and a girl who “keeps the villains at bay.” Lines like “I’ve been in this town so long that back in the city I’ve been taken for lost and gone” suggest displacement and nostalgia, while the chorus—“Heroes and villains, just see what you’ve done”—implies a moral reckoning. The dense, poetic lyrics, delivered through Brian and Carl’s vocals, create a dreamlike narrative open to interpretation.

The song’s themes reflect the 1960s’ fascination with myth, identity, and cultural upheaval. The hero-villain dichotomy mirrors the era’s social conflicts—civil rights, Vietnam War protests, and generational divides—while the Western imagery taps into America’s romanticized past, a counterpoint to the psychedelic present. The narrator’s sense of being “lost and gone” resonates with the counterculture’s search for meaning, aligning with Smile’s broader exploration of innocence and experience. Unlike Pet Sounds’ personal intimacy, Heroes and Villains is expansive, blending humor, irony, and surrealism to comment on human nature.

Musically, Heroes and Villains conveys a whirlwind of emotions. The episodic structure, with its shifts from jaunty verses to dramatic choruses to saloon-style interludes, evokes a musical collage, mirroring the narrative’s fragmentation. The instrumentation—banjo, organ, and percussion—creates a vaudevillian, almost theatrical vibe, while the harmonies, among the Beach Boys’ most intricate, add warmth and grandeur. Brian’s production, with its dynamic contrasts and sound effects, immerses listeners in a sonic landscape, from dusty plains to bustling cantinas.

Culturally, Heroes and Villains captured the 1967 zeitgeist, blending Americana with psychedelic experimentation. It reinforced the Beach Boys’ role as innovators, though its complexity marked a shift from their accessible hits, alienating some fans. The song’s male-centric narrative and abstract lyrics reflect the era’s artistic trends, though its universality mitigates modern critique. Its enduring appeal lies in its bold ambition, evoking a mythic America caught between heroism and chaos.

Lyrics

I’ve been in this town so long that back in the city
I’ve been taken for lost and gone
And unknown for a long, long time
Fell in love years ago
With an innocent girl
From the Spanish and Indian home
Home of the heroes and villains

Once at night Catillian squared the fight
And she was right in the rain of the bullets that eventually brought her down
But she’s still dancing in the night
Unafraid of what a dude’ll do in a town full of heroes and villains

Heroes and villains
Just see what you’ve done
Heroes and villains
Just see what you’ve done

Stand or fall I know there
Shall be peace in the valley
And it’s all an affair
Of my life with the heroes and villains

My children were raised
You know they suddenly rise
They started slow long ago
Head to toe healthy wealthy and wise

I’ve been in this town so long
So long to the city
I’m fit with the stuff
To ride in the rough
And sunny down snuff I’m alright
By the heroes and

Heroes and villains
Just see what you’ve done
Heroes and villains
Just see what you’ve done

Video