“Cried Like a Baby,” released in February 1971 by Metromedia Records, was a notable single in the career of Bobby Sherman, a prominent teen idol of the late 1960s and early 1970s. Born Robert Cabot Sherman Jr. on July 22, 1943, in Santa Monica, California, Sherman had already achieved widespread fame with hits like “Little Woman” (1969), “La La La (If I Had You)” (1969), “Easy Come, Easy Go” (1970), “Hey, Mister Sun” (1970), and “Julie, Do Ya Love Me” (1970). By 1971, Sherman’s chart dominance was beginning to soften, but he remained a beloved figure, known for his wholesome image, shaggy hair, and heartfelt vocals. “Cried Like a Baby” reached No. 16 on the Billboard Hot 100, No. 10 in Canada, and No. 9 on the Billboard Easy Listening chart, demonstrating his continued appeal, though it did not achieve the gold certification of his earlier hits.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
Written by Craig Doerge and Mark James, with production by Ward Sylvester, the song marked a shift toward a more introspective, emotionally raw sound compared to Sherman’s earlier bubblegum pop hits. The recording featured a skilled ensemble of session musicians, though specific details about the lineup are less documented than for his previous singles. The single’s B-side was “Is Anybody There,” a lesser-known track. “Cried Like a Baby” was included on Sherman’s album Portrait of Bobby, released in 1971, which showcased a more mature side of his artistry as he navigated a changing musical landscape.
In 1971, Sherman was balancing multiple facets of his career. His role in the ABC series Here Come the Brides (1968–1970) had ended, but he starred in the short-lived Getting Together (1971–1972), a sitcom spin-off of The Partridge Family. His music career, amplified by regular features in teen magazines like Tiger Beat and 16 Magazine, continued to resonate with young fans, particularly teenage girls, though the bubblegum pop craze was giving way to soft rock, folk, and glam influences. The release of “Cried Like a Baby” came during a transitional period for Sherman, as he sought to evolve his sound while maintaining his connection with his audience.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
The song arrived in a cultural context where emotional vulnerability in music was gaining traction, with artists like James Taylor and Carole King exploring introspective themes. The early 1970s were marked by social and political challenges, including the Vietnam War and economic uncertainty, making songs about personal struggles and heartbreak relatable to a wide audience. “Cried Like a Baby” tapped into this sentiment, offering a poignant reflection on love and loss that contrasted with Sherman’s earlier, more upbeat hits.
Reasons Behind the Creation of “Cried Like a Baby”
The creation of “Cried Like a Baby” was a deliberate effort by Metromedia Records to showcase Bobby Sherman’s versatility and emotional depth as his career entered a new phase. After a string of romantic, upbeat hits, Sherman’s label aimed to keep him relevant in a shifting musical landscape by introducing a song that explored deeper, more vulnerable themes. Craig Doerge, a songwriter and keyboardist who later worked with artists like Jackson Browne, and Mark James, known for penning Elvis Presley’s “Suspicious Minds,” crafted a track that aligned with Sherman’s sincere persona while pushing him toward a more mature, introspective sound.
The song’s melancholic tone and confessional lyrics were designed to resonate with Sherman’s core audience of young fans, who were growing up and facing their own emotional challenges, while also appealing to adult listeners through its easy listening chart performance. Producer Ward Sylvester, who had taken over from Jackie Mills for some of Sherman’s later work, aimed to create a polished yet emotionally raw sound, balancing the song’s pop sensibilities with a folk-rock edge. The choice of Doerge and James as songwriters reflected a strategic move to align Sherman with the era’s trend toward introspective, singer-songwriter-style music.
Sherman’s personal context likely influenced the song’s authenticity, even though he did not write it. At 27, he was navigating the pressures of fame, a demanding career, and his marriage to Patti Carnel. His ability to convey genuine emotion—whether joy, longing, or heartache—made him an ideal interpreter for a song about heartbreak and regret. The song’s theme of crying “like a baby” over lost love may have resonated with Sherman’s own experiences or those of his fans, who often wrote to him about their romantic struggles in fan letters published in teen magazines.
The cultural landscape of 1971 played a significant role in the song’s creation. As the early 1970s saw a shift toward more personal, emotionally honest music, artists were increasingly exploring themes of vulnerability and self-reflection. “Cried Like a Baby” fit this trend, offering a contrast to the upbeat optimism of Sherman’s earlier hits while maintaining his signature sincerity. The song’s release was timed to keep Sherman competitive in a market that included rising stars like Donny Osmond and established acts like Neil Diamond, while also appealing to listeners seeking relatable, heartfelt content amidst the era’s social challenges.
The song also served as a way for Sherman to demonstrate his growth as an artist. As his teen idol status began to evolve, “Cried Like a Baby” allowed him to connect with fans on a deeper level, addressing universal experiences of heartbreak and regret. Its introspective nature and mature themes signaled Sherman’s desire to move beyond the bubblegum pop formula, even as he remained a heartthrob for his loyal fanbase.
Content and Themes Conveyed Through “Cried Like a Baby”
“Cried Like a Baby” is a poignant, introspective pop ballad that explores themes of heartbreak, regret, and emotional vulnerability. Delivered with Bobby Sherman’s soulful, tremulous vocals, the lyrics tell the story of a narrator who is grappling with the pain of losing a loved one due to his own mistakes. The song’s raw emotional honesty, paired with a melodic folk-pop arrangement, marks a departure from Sherman’s earlier, more lighthearted hits, offering a deeply relatable reflection on love’s consequences.
The lyrics open with a stark admission: “I cried like a baby when you walked away / I thought I’d die, I didn’t know what to say.” This sets the tone for the song’s confessional narrative, as the narrator lays bare his devastation over the end of a relationship. The phrase “cried like a baby” evokes a powerful image of unrestrained emotion, suggesting a loss of control and a return to a childlike state of helplessness. The narrator’s vulnerability is palpable, resonating with listeners who have experienced the sting of rejection or regret.
The chorus amplifies the song’s emotional weight, with lines like “I cried like a baby, oh, what a fool I’ve been / I let you slip away, now I’m payin’ for my sin.” Here, the narrator takes responsibility for the relationship’s failure, acknowledging his mistakes as the cause of his pain. The use of “sin” adds a dramatic, almost biblical weight to his regret, framing the loss as a moral failing as well as an emotional one. Sherman’s delivery—quivering with remorse—enhances the song’s sincerity, making the narrator’s self-reproach feel authentic and heartfelt.
The verses delve deeper into the narrator’s reflection, recounting the moments that led to the breakup. Lyrics like “I took your love for granted, thought it would always be / Now I’m alone, and you’re no longer here with me” reveal a sense of complacency that cost him dearly. The narrator’s realization comes too late, and the song captures the anguish of hindsight, where clarity arrives only after irreversible damage. The imagery of being “alone” underscores the emptiness left in the wake of the loved one’s departure, a universal experience that connects with listeners of all ages.
Thematically, “Cried Like a Baby” explores the pain of self-inflicted heartbreak and the courage to confront one’s flaws. The narrator’s willingness to admit his mistakes and express raw emotion challenges traditional notions of masculinity, aligning with the early 1970s’ cultural shift toward emotional openness in music. The song’s folk-pop melody, with its gentle acoustic strumming and understated orchestration, complements the lyrics’ intimacy, creating a mood of quiet devastation that invites empathy.
The song’s universal appeal lies in its relatable portrayal of regret and loss. For Sherman’s young fans, navigating the complexities of crushes and early relationships, the song offered a cathartic reflection of their own emotional struggles. For older listeners, its easy listening appeal and mature themes provided a poignant reminder of love’s fragility. The gender-neutral framing of the loved one—never explicitly gendered in the lyrics—allowed listeners to project their own experiences onto the narrative, enhancing its accessibility.
The song also reflects the cultural mood of 1971, when music increasingly served as a space for personal storytelling. Its introspective tone and emotional depth aligned with the era’s singer-songwriter movement, offering a contrast to the upbeat optimism of Sherman’s earlier hits. Ultimately, “Cried Like a Baby” conveys a timeless message about the cost of taking love for granted and the redemptive power of acknowledging one’s mistakes, making it a standout in Sherman’s catalog for its honesty and emotional resonance.