“I Want to Hear It from Her,” released in 1963 by Dot Records, was an early single by Bobby Sherman, recorded before his rise to fame as a teen idol in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Born Robert Cabot Sherman Jr. on July 22, 1943, in Santa Monica, California, Sherman was a 20-year-old aspiring singer and actor at the time, still years away from chart-topping hits like “Little Woman” (1969) and “Julie, Do Ya Love Me” (1970). The song did not chart, reflecting Sherman’s early struggles to break into the competitive music industry. Written by Fred Anisfield and Tony Bruno, the single featured a pop ballad style with a touch of early 1960s teen pop, backed by “Nobody’s Sweetheart” as the B-side. It was later included on the 1990 compilation What Came Before (Teen Ager Records). Released during Sherman’s formative years, the song coincided with his efforts to establish a music career while pursuing minor acting roles and local performances.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
Reasons Behind the Creation of “I Want to Hear It from Her”
The creation of “I Want to Hear It from Her” was part of Bobby Sherman’s early efforts to launch a music career in the competitive early 1960s pop scene, following his initial recordings with the help of teen idol Sal Mineo. In 1962, Mineo, known for his role in Rebel Without a Cause and his own music career, had written and arranged two songs for Sherman, “Judy, You’ll Never Know” and “The Telegram,” released on Starcrest Records. These early singles, though unsuccessful, gave Sherman valuable studio experience. By 1963, Sherman had signed with Dot Records, a larger label known for artists like Pat Boone, in hopes of gaining broader exposure. The release of “I Want to Hear It from Her” was a continuation of his attempt to establish himself as a viable pop singer, capitalizing on his youthful charm and smooth vocal style.
Songwriters Fred Anisfield and Tony Bruno, who had experience crafting pop and doo-wop tracks, were chosen to write a song that fit the teen-oriented market of the early 1960s, dominated by romantic ballads and artists like Bobby Vee and Ricky Nelson. The song’s straightforward, emotional narrative was designed to showcase Sherman’s vocal sincerity and appeal to young listeners, particularly teenage girls, who were the primary audience for teen idols. Dot Records likely saw Sherman as a potential heartthrob, given his good looks and earnest delivery, and aimed to position him within the crowded field of young male singers. The production, though modest compared to Sherman’s later Metromedia hits, incorporated the clean, melodic sound typical of early 1960s pop, with simple instrumentation to highlight his voice.
---> Scroll down for the VIDEO
Sherman’s personal context influenced his involvement. At 20, he was a determined young performer from a middle-class family in Van Nuys, California, with no significant industry connections. His early gigs at local venues and school events had built his confidence, but breaking into the national music scene required persistence and opportunity. Working with Dot Records offered a step up from the small-scale Starcrest release, and Sherman likely saw the single as a chance to prove his potential. The song’s theme of seeking romantic clarity may have resonated with Sherman’s own experiences as a young man navigating relationships, though the track was a professional assignment rather than a personal composition.
The cultural landscape of 1963 shaped the song’s creation. The early 1960s were a peak period for teen pop, with radio stations playing romantic, harmony-driven songs that captured the innocence and optimism of the pre-Beatles era. Teen idols like Frankie Avalon and Paul Anka were cultural icons, featured in magazines like 16 and on TV shows like American Bandstand. “I Want to Hear It from Her” was crafted to fit this mold, offering a relatable love song that could compete in a market filled with similar releases. Its release came before Sherman’s breakthrough as a house singer on Shindig! (1964–1966) and his starring role in Here Come the Brides (1968–1970), but it contributed to his early industry experience. The song’s lack of chart success reflects the intense competition of the time, where many young artists’ singles went unnoticed, but it served as a building block for Sherman’s later career.
The song’s creation also aligned with Dot Records’ strategy to test new talent. Sherman’s signing with the label was likely a low-risk investment, given his youth and potential appeal. The choice of Anisfield and Bruno as songwriters suggests an attempt to create a commercially viable track, though limited promotion and distribution likely hindered its reach. For Sherman, the single was a chance to refine his craft and gain exposure, even if it did not yield immediate success, paving the way for his eventual rise with Metromedia Records in 1969.
Content and Themes Conveyed Through “I Want to Hear It from Her”
“I Want to Hear It from Her” is a tender, early 1960s pop ballad that explores themes of romantic uncertainty, longing, and the need for direct emotional confirmation. Delivered with Bobby Sherman’s youthful, earnest vocals, the lyrics tell the story of a narrator who hears rumors or hints that his love interest may care for him but insists on hearing the truth directly from her. The song’s simple, melodic structure, featuring gentle guitar strums, soft percussion, and a clean production style, creates an intimate, heartfelt atmosphere typical of teen pop ballads of the era, contrasting with the polished bubblegum pop of Sherman’s later hits like “Little Woman” or “La La La (If I Had You).”
The lyrics open with a sense of doubt and anticipation: “They tell me she loves me, but I can’t be sure / I want to hear it from her, just to know it’s true.” This establishes the song’s central theme of seeking clarity in love, as the narrator grapples with secondhand information about his beloved’s feelings. The phrase “I want to hear it from her” is both a plea and a declaration, emphasizing the narrator’s need for authenticity and direct communication. The repetition of this line throughout the song underscores his emotional urgency, reflecting the vulnerability of young love. Sherman’s delivery, though less refined than in his later recordings, carries a raw sincerity that suits the song’s straightforward narrative, making the narrator’s longing relatable to listeners.
The chorus amplifies the narrator’s desire for certainty, with lines like “I want to hear it from her, those words so sweet / Till she says she loves me, my heart won’t beat.” The imagery of “words so sweet” and a heart that “won’t beat” conveys the intensity of the narrator’s emotions, portraying love as a life-altering force. The exaggerated language—common in teen pop of the time—captures the melodramatic perspective of youth, where romantic confirmation feels like a matter of survival. The chorus’s catchy, singable melody, paired with Sherman’s emotive performance, invites listeners to empathize with the narrator’s yearning, creating a sense of shared anticipation.
The verses delve into the narrator’s inner turmoil, highlighting his reluctance to trust rumors. Lyrics like “Friends say she’s mine, they see it in her eyes / But till she tells me, I’ll never realize” suggest that external validation is insufficient without her direct confession. The reference to “her eyes” as a sign of love introduces a visual element, common in romantic ballads, that paints the love interest as both mysterious and alluring. The narrator’s insistence on hearing her words reflects a desire for mutual vulnerability, a theme that resonates with the early 1960s’ idealized view of romance as pure and honest. The song avoids specifying the reasons for his uncertainty—whether due to shyness, distance, or doubt—allowing listeners to project their own experiences onto the narrative.
Thematically, “I Want to Hear It from Her” captures the universal experience of seeking reassurance in love, particularly the anxiety of unconfirmed feelings. The narrator’s focus on direct communication reflects a broader human need for clarity and connection, especially poignant in the context of adolescent romance. The song’s pop ballad style, with its clean harmonies and melodic simplicity, aligns with the early 1960s’ emphasis on emotional, teen-oriented music, evoking artists like Bobby Vinton or Gene Pitney. Its focus on romantic uncertainty made it relatable to young listeners navigating crushes and the complexities of early relationships.
The song’s appeal lies in its emotional honesty and accessibility. Though it did not gain commercial traction, its inclusion on What Came Before (1990) highlights its historical value as a snapshot of Sherman’s early career. The gender-specific focus on a female love interest situates the song within the teen pop tradition, though the theme of seeking truth in love transcends gender, inviting broad identification. The song’s modest production reflects the budget constraints of Sherman’s early recordings, but Sherman’s vocal sincerity compensates, foreshadowing the charisma that would later make him a star.
The song also reflects the cultural mood of 1963, when teen pop ballads provided an emotional outlet for young listeners in a pre-Beatles era of relative cultural innocence. Its emphasis on romantic clarity aligns with the era’s idealized view of love as sincere and unspoken until confirmed. The choice of a generic female pronoun—“her”—rather than a specific name like “Judy” in his previous single, broadens its relatability, making it a universal plea for love’s truth.
Ultimately, “I Want to Hear It from Her” conveys a timeless message about the vulnerability and hope inherent in seeking love’s confirmation. Its tender lyrics, melodic simplicity, and Sherman’s earnest performance capture the essence of a young heart yearning for certainty, offering a poignant glimpse into his early artistry and the romantic sensibilities of the early 1960s.