Shake Hands and Walk Away Cryin’ – Lou Christie (1967)

Reason for Creation

By 1967, Lou Christie, born Lugee Alfredo Giovanni Sacco in Glenwillard, Pennsylvania, was a seasoned pop artist navigating a shifting musical landscape. After achieving major success with hits like “Lightnin’ Strikes” (1966) and “Rhapsody in the Rain” (1966) on MGM Records, Christie faced challenges maintaining chart dominance as rock, psychedelia, and soul began to dominate the airwaves. His partnership with Twyla Herbert, a classically trained musician with a penchant for dramatic and mystical themes, had been central to his earlier successes. However, after parting ways with MGM and briefly working with Colpix Records, Christie signed with Columbia Records, a major label with a strong roster, including Bob Dylan and Barbra Streisand, offering a fresh opportunity to redefine his sound.

“Shake Hands and Walk Away Cryin'” was crafted to showcase Christie’s emotional depth and vocal versatility while aligning with the soul-infused pop trends of 1967. Unlike his earlier, more theatrical hits, this song leaned into a smoother, more introspective style, drawing inspiration from Motown and the emotive ballads of artists like Smokey Robinson. Christie and Herbert aimed to create a relatable narrative about the quiet pain of a breakup, a theme that resonated with young adults navigating the complexities of love. The song’s understated production and focus on personal vulnerability reflected Christie’s desire to move away from the controversial, suggestive themes of his past releases, such as “Rhapsody in the Rain,” and instead connect with listeners on a more universal, emotional level.

The track was recorded in New York with a team of seasoned session musicians, under the guidance of producer Wes Farrell, known for his work with The McCoys and later The Partridge Family. The choice to incorporate Motown-style elements, like a prominent bassline and layered harmonies, was a deliberate nod to the era’s soul boom, while still retaining Christie’s signature falsetto and pop sensibilities. The song’s release came at a time when Christie was transitioning from teen idol to a more mature artist, and though it didn’t achieve the chart success of his earlier hits, it was a testament to his ability to adapt and deliver heartfelt performances in a competitive market.

Content Conveyed Through the Song

“Shake Hands and Walk Away Cryin'” is a tender exploration of heartbreak, dignity, and the internal struggle to conceal pain during a breakup. The song’s narrator faces the end of a romantic relationship and chooses to part ways gracefully, maintaining composure in public while privately wrestling with profound sorrow. The title itself encapsulates this duality: the act of shaking hands symbolizes a civilized farewell, while “walk away cryin’” reveals the emotional toll hidden beneath the surface. The opening lines set the scene with quiet resignation: “We shake hands, say goodbye, no one knows I’m dyin’ / I’ll just walk away cryin’, keep my tears inside.” This establishes the narrator’s determination to preserve his pride, even as his heart breaks.

The narrative unfolds as a deeply personal confession, with the narrator addressing his former lover indirectly, reflecting on the pain of letting go. He acknowledges the finality of their parting, singing, “You’re free to go, I won’t beg you to stay / But my heart’s breaking as I watch you walk away.” The lyrics convey a sense of selflessness, as the narrator prioritizes his partner’s happiness over his own, but they also reveal the cost of this sacrifice. The repeated phrase “walk away cryin’” becomes a mantra of sorts, emphasizing the contrast between his outward calm and inner turmoil. Christie’s vocal performance is the emotional linchpin, shifting from a soft, conversational tone in the verses to a soaring falsetto in the chorus, where he stretches notes to convey the depth of his anguish.

Musically, the song is a polished blend of pop and soul, with a Motown-inspired arrangement that balances melancholy with a subtle groove. The production features a prominent bassline, crisp percussion, and gentle guitar strums, creating a steady rhythm that mirrors the narrator’s measured steps as he walks away. The backing vocals, likely provided by a studio ensemble, add a layer of warmth, with their harmonies echoing Christie’s lines in a call-and-response pattern, such as “Cryin’, cryin’.” These harmonies evoke the doo-wop influences of Christie’s earlier work while aligning with the soulful sound of 1967 hits like The Temptations’ “My Girl.” The arrangement remains restrained, allowing Christie’s vocals to take center stage, with occasional flourishes of strings adding a touch of elegance to the track’s emotional core.

The lyrics delve into the theme of hidden pain, a universal experience that resonates with anyone who has had to mask their feelings. The narrator’s resolve to “smile though my heart is torn” highlights his commitment to dignity, even as he admits, “No one sees the tears that fall when I’m alone.” This vulnerability is what makes the song so affecting, as it captures the quiet moments of grief that follow a public farewell. Fan interpretations on platforms like SongMeanings have described the song as “a masterclass in understated heartbreak,” noting how Christie’s voice conveys a sincerity that makes the listener feel the weight of his unspoken sorrow. The imagery of tears falling in solitude adds a layer of intimacy, inviting listeners to connect with the narrator’s private struggle.

The song’s cultural context enriches its meaning. Released in 1967, a year defined by the Summer of Love and groundbreaking albums like The Beatles’ Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band and Aretha Franklin’s I Never Loved a Man the Way I Love You, “Shake Hands and Walk Away Cryin'” reflects the era’s growing emphasis on emotional authenticity in music. Its soulful undertones align with the mainstream embrace of Black music, while its pop structure keeps it accessible to a broad audience. The song’s focus on personal sacrifice and quiet suffering also resonates with the social undercurrents of the time, as young people grappled with the pressures of conformity and the emotional complexities of relationships in a rapidly changing world.

The production choices amplify the song’s emotional resonance. The use of reverb on Christie’s vocals creates a sense of intimacy, as if he’s confiding his pain directly to the listener. The bassline and percussion provide a subtle pulse, evoking the steady rhythm of walking away, while the strings in the chorus add a touch of cinematic grandeur, underscoring the narrator’s emotional climax. The bridge introduces a moment of reflection, with Christie singing, “I’ll keep my head up high, though I’m breaking inside / No one will know how much I’ve cried.” Accompanied by a softer arrangement, this section highlights the narrator’s resilience, adding depth to his character as someone who chooses grace over despair.

The song also reflects Christie’s Italian-American heritage, with its emotive delivery and dramatic phrasing drawing parallels to the crooners of the era, like Tony Bennett or Al Martino. Its understated elegance, combined with its soulful groove, made it a compelling addition to the 1967 charts, a year dominated by diverse hits from The Monkees’ “Daydream Believer” to Marvin Gaye’s “I Heard It Through the Grapevine.” Though it didn’t achieve the commercial success of Christie’s earlier hits, “Shake Hands and Walk Away Cryin'” showcases his ability to convey profound emotion with subtlety and grace. Its enduring appeal, as seen in its inclusion on oldies playlists and streaming platforms, lies in its timeless portrayal of heartbreak, delivered with Christie’s unmistakable voice and a sincerity that makes every hidden tear feel palpable.

Video